The Unsung Heroes of Christmas: Jewish Composers and Their Iconic Holiday Songs

Views & Reviews: essays and book reviews

The holiday season is synonymous with joyous melodies that echo through homes, shops, and streets, creating a soundtrack of warmth and cheer. It’s a delightful irony that many of the most beloved Christmas songs—quintessential expressions of a Christian holiday—were composed by Jewish songwriters. This phenomenon speaks to the universality of music and the uniquely American cultural melting pot, where traditions overlap and enrich one another. In this essay, we’ll explore the contributions of Jewish composers to Christmas music and highlight several enduring classics.

A Historical and Cultural Context

Jewish immigrants, especially those arriving in the United States during the late 19th and early 20th centuries, found themselves in a predominantly Christian society. While retaining their religious and cultural identities, they were eager to assimilate into the broader American culture. The entertainment industry—spanning theater, film, and music—provided a fertile ground for Jewish creativity. Songwriting, in particular, offered a way to contribute to the American cultural tapestry, including its Christmas traditions.

For Jewish composers, writing Christmas songs was not an act of religious devotion but a celebration of the holiday's secular and inclusive aspects—family, love, warmth, and goodwill. These themes transcend religious boundaries, allowing Jewish songwriters to create music that resonates with people of all faiths.

Irving Berlin and "White Christmas"

Irving Berlin, born Israel Beilin, stands as perhaps the most iconic example of a Jewish composer contributing to the Christmas canon. His 1942 masterpiece "White Christmas," performed by Bing Crosby, is a cornerstone of holiday music. Berlin’s poignant lyrics evoke a nostalgic and peaceful image of Christmas, appealing to a nation longing for comfort during the tumultuous years of World War II. The song’s universal appeal lies in its simplicity and emotional resonance, making it the best-selling single of all time.

Interestingly, Berlin himself did not celebrate Christmas. However, his ability to tap into the holiday's emotional core exemplifies the empathetic artistry that allowed Jewish composers to create enduring works in this genre.

Mel Tormé and "The Christmas Song"

Another timeless Christmas classic, "The Christmas Song" (commonly known by its opening line, "Chestnuts roasting on an open fire"), was co-written by Mel Tormé and Robert Wells, both of whom were Jewish. Written during a sweltering summer in 1945, the song captures the essence of holiday coziness with vivid imagery and a lilting melody. Nat King Cole’s iconic recording of the song cemented its place in the pantheon of holiday music. Tormé’s jazz background and lyrical sensitivity shine in this quintessential ode to Christmas.

Johnny Marks: A Prolific Holiday Hitmaker

Johnny Marks may not be a household name, but his contributions to Christmas music are extraordinary. A Jewish composer with a knack for storytelling, Marks wrote several holiday hits, including "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer," "Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree," and "A Holly Jolly Christmas." His songs, characterized by their catchy melodies and upbeat charm, have become staples of holiday celebrations.

Marks’ ability to craft songs that appeal to both children and adults underscores his deep understanding of the holiday's communal spirit. His work demonstrates how Jewish composers often approached Christmas music with a sense of fun and accessibility.

Jule Styne and "Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow!"

Jule Styne, another prominent Jewish songwriter, collaborated with lyricist Sammy Cahn (also Jewish) to create "Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow!" in 1945. Though not explicitly about Christmas, the song’s wintry theme has made it a holiday standard. Its cheerful tone and evocative imagery capture the season's joy, blending romance and nostalgia in a way that feels inherently festive.

Beyond Secular Christmas: The Broader Impact

The success of Jewish composers in creating Christmas music reveals the power of art to bridge cultural divides. These songwriters approached Christmas not as a religious celebration but as a cultural phenomenon that emphasizes universal values. Their songs reflect themes of home, love, and joy—concepts that resonate across faiths and traditions.

Moreover, their contributions to Christmas music have enriched the holiday for everyone. Whether sung around a family hearth or played in bustling department stores, these songs have become shared experiences, creating a sense of unity during a season that encourages togetherness.

Why Christmas?

It’s worth considering why Jewish composers were drawn to Christmas music in the first place. The answer lies partly in the commercial opportunities of the genre. Christmas music has always been a lucrative field, and Jewish composers, many of whom were already successful in Tin Pan Alley and Hollywood, recognized its potential.

More importantly, Christmas as a cultural event offered an opportunity for Jewish songwriters to express sentiments that transcended religious boundaries. Through their music, they contributed to a holiday that, for many, is less about theology and more about the spirit of kindness and goodwill.

A Legacy of Harmony

The contributions of Jewish composers to Christmas music highlight the inclusive spirit of both the holiday and the American cultural landscape. By embracing the secular aspects of Christmas, these songwriters created works that have endured for decades, bringing joy to countless listeners.

In a world often divided by religious and cultural differences, the legacy of these Jewish composers serves as a reminder of music’s ability to unite. The melodies of Berlin, Tormé, Marks, Styne, and others continue to echo through time, proving that the true essence of the holiday season—peace, love, and understanding—knows no boundaries.